In the Wall Street Journal, "Dilbert" Creator Scott Adams writes that we need a good new idea to save the world. He includes this observation:
"Try to imagine that the idea that saves the country is an entirely new one. It's too much of a stretch to imagine that a stale idea would suddenly become acceptable. In fact, that's the dividing line between imagination and insanity. Only crazy people imagine that bad ideas can suddenly become good if you keep trying them."
Oh, if only more people, both inside and outside of government, believed that. Anyway, he also adds this about how to come up with good ideas:
"I spent some time working in the television industry, and I learned a technique that writers use. It's called "the bad version." When you feel that a plot solution exists, but you can't yet imagine it, you describe instead a bad version that has no purpose other than stimulating the other writers to imagine a better version."
That really rang a bell. I also spent some time in the TV industry and occasionally still do, and this phenomenon does play a big role. You always protect yourself by saying, "This isn't right, but what if--" And you come up with an approximation, something that may or may not be close to being workable. Spurred by the obvious incompetence of your idea (but also stimulated by some element of it) the others then chime in with their also "not right" ideas, and often a right idea emerges. Or you get so tired that you accept the best of the "not right" ideas.
Digression: I'm guessing the exhaustion factor was at play when the pilot episode of "No Ordinary Family" was written. I watched this last night. It's about how a normal family suddenly develops superpowers. The father gets shot at the police station where he works but the bullet just bounces off him. He decides to test his new powers by going to a batting cage where you can have baseballs shot at you at high velocity. He sets it to maximum and easily catches the balls and doesn't get hurt when one hits him. Then his friend, who is a cop, shows up and our new super man comes up with this idea: his friend should shoot him. Why? Just to be certain this super thing is really effective. OK. Time out. He's already been shot once, so basically he knows the answer already. But let's say he's not sure...in which case getting shot would kill him. We now go to the writers' room, where a long working session is in progress:
Writer: "This isn't right, but what if he asks his cop friend to shoot him?"
Story Editor: "Wait a minute, if he's in doubt that would be incredibly stupid. And if he's not in doubt, why bother?"
Producer: "Yeah....god, is that the time? I have to get home or my wife will kill me. Go ahead and use that shooting friend thing."
Apparently things don't improve (the show has been on a while in the US, it just started here in the UK). One of the reviews on imbd.com says, "I'm about 6 episodes in and I can't stop yelling, "Are you stupid? Why would you do that?" I'm sorry to insult all the people who like this show, but this show is made for people who don't think."
Do use bad ideas to spur your thinking but don't stop short of a good one. If it makes you uncomfortable to come up with bad ideas intentionally, invent an imaginary friend (why should only kids have the fun?) and make him or her someone who comes up with only bad ideas. Present your problem, imagine a bad idea coming from your IF and riff off that.
Hey maybe the writers of "No Ordinary Family" could come up with an IF who thinks of only GOOD ideas.
You'll find 75 ways to be more creative in my book, "Creativity Now!" published by Pearson and available from Amazon and other online and off line booksellers.